Two technologies for solving mobile device filtering: SAW and BAW

Filters play a crucial role in signal processing by eliminating unwanted frequency components while preserving the desired ones. Depending on their design, filters can be categorized into four main types: low-pass, high-pass, band-pass, and band-stop (or band-reject) filters. Each type serves a specific purpose in controlling which frequencies are allowed to pass through or are blocked.

Today, we won’t dive into the basics of filtering but instead focus on two key technologies used in mobile devices: Surface Acoustic Wave (SAW) and Bulk Acoustic Wave (BAW) filters. As mobile networks evolve from 2G to 4G and beyond, these technologies have become essential in meeting the growing demands for better performance and miniaturization.

Surface Acoustic Wave (SAW) filters are widely used in 2G and 3G devices, particularly in receiver front-ends, duplexers, and receive filters. They offer low insertion loss and good rejection, making them suitable for high-bandwidth applications. Their compact size also makes them a preferred choice over traditional cavity and ceramic filters.

One of the major advantages of SAW filters is their ability to support high-frequency applications up to 1.9 GHz, including standards like GSM, CDMA, and 3G. With advancements in wafer-level packaging, SAW filters can now be integrated with multiple frequency bands on a single chip, which is increasingly important as smartphones continue to add more features and connectivity options.

However, SAW filters face challenges at higher frequencies. Above around 1 GHz, their selectivity decreases, and they are typically limited to medium-performance applications up to 2.5 GHz. Additionally, SAW filters are highly sensitive to temperature changes—rising temperatures can cause a frequency response shift of up to 4 MHz. This becomes a critical issue as modern devices operate across wide temperature ranges, from -20°C to 85°C, and as guard bands narrow in newer network standards.

Bulk Acoustic Wave (BAW) technology offers superior performance at higher frequencies, with lower insertion loss and a higher quality factor compared to SAW. It enables the creation of narrow-band filters with steep transition bands and excellent suppression, making it ideal for handling complex interference issues in modern communication systems.

BAW filters operate efficiently around 1.5 GHz, complementing SAW technology, which performs better at lower frequencies. They can handle frequencies up to 6 GHz, making them suitable for new LTE bands above 1.9 GHz. BAW is also effective in coexistence scenarios, such as LTE/Wi-Fi filters.

As the frequency increases, the size of BAW filters actually decreases, making them ideal for demanding 3G and 4G applications. Moreover, BAW filters are less affected by temperature variations, even at wide bandwidths, offering greater stability in real-world conditions.

Modern smartphones may need to support up to 15 different frequency bands for 2G, 3G, and 4G, along with Wi-Fi, Bluetooth, and GNSS. This means a single device could require as many as 30 to 40 filters, highlighting the importance of advanced filtering solutions like SAW and BAW in today’s mobile ecosystem.

Ceramic Substrates

Shaanxi Xinlong Metal Electro-mechanical Co., Ltd. , https://www.cnxlalloys.com